OpinionTrending Commentary

China Holds All The Cards In The Great Green Energy Game



The limited supply of critical raw materials risks jeopardizing the world’s renewable energy transition.

That was the warning contained in a recent OECD publication, “Raw Materials Critical for the Green Transition.” According to the OECD, China, by utilizing its chokehold on the production and processing of critical materials, is drawing up plans to disrupt the green energy transition.

Such a plan, if executed, would throw sand in the gears of the Biden administration’s Green New Deal, a pipe dream which aims to eliminate fossil fuels as a form of energy generation in the U.S. by 2035. This reality makes one wonder why the U.S. is so intent on provoking China.

Why are critical materials, such as rare-earth-minerals like neodymium, dysprosium and terbium, so important? They’re crucial to produce magnets found in everything from wind turbines to electric vehicles. For example, a 3 mega-watt direct-drive wind turbine contains close to two tons of those magnets.

Stunningly, China is responsible for 90% of the production of these rare-earth magnets.

It’s not just in magnets where China excels. The Chinese have taken control over a variety of other critical materials that are essential in the global transition to a “green” economy.

In the sphere of batteries alone, China dominates the production of the necessary raw materials (i.e., lithium, natural graphite and synthetic graphite). China has also reached the commanding heights of the chemical processing required for inputs in the production of battery anodes and cells. And that’s not all. Chinese firms produce 72% of the world’s solar modules and 45% of its wind turbines.

China’s threat to the green transition is not idle. Over the last decade, its grip around rare earths has tightened. In the 11 years prior to 2020, Beijing increased the number of export restrictions on critical raw materials needed for electric cars and renewable energy (read: lithium, cobalt, manganese) nine fold.

And recently, according to the most widely circulated financial newspaper in the world, Japan’s famed Nikkei, President Xi Jinping has even considered a total ban on the export of components used in rare earth magnets.

While the reserves of rare earths are scattered around the globe, 40% are found in China. When it comes to extracting them, over 70% of rare earths are mined in China. Further downstream, China trumps all, processing nearly 90% of rare earths.

But that’s not all. China has an outsized dominance in what one of us (Hanke) has termed the Three Ms: 1) Mining and Mineral Engineering, 2) Metallurgical Engineering and 3) Materials Science and Engineering. When it comes to rare earths and the Three Ms, China has long acknowledged their strategic hegemony.

As the Global Times, a state-owned Chinese newspaper, put it: rare earths are “an ace in Beijing’s hand.” Back in 1987, Deng Xiaoping pointedly asserted that “the Middle East has oil; China has rare earths.”

But how did China become so dominant in the Three Ms? One of us (Hanke), who landed his first faculty position and cut his teeth on mineral economics in the late 1960s at the Colorado School of Mines, the world’s top Mineral & Mining Engineering school, has long suspected that China must have invested heavily in the Three Ms.

When it comes to the world’s top-flight universities, China was nowhere to be found in the top 20 in 2022. The U.S. dominates, with 15 of the top 20 universities.

But, when we move into the Three Ms, things change dramatically. China dominates in Mining and Mineral Engineering, with half of the world’s top-20 programs in those fields. The U.S. only accounts for 10% of the total.

When we move to Metallurgical Engineering, China holds down 60% of the top-20 programs, with the U.S. only accounting for 15%.

In Materials Science and Engineering, China slips a bit, but still holds down 35% of the world’s first-class programs, with the U.S. accounting for 45% of the total.

Just how has China secured such a position in educational fields relating to the Three Ms? It’s simple. For decades, the Chinese Communist Party has poured money into education and development of the Three Ms.

For example, in 2001, Premier Zhu Rongji formally launched China’s 10th five-year plan for National Economic and Social Development. The plan aimed to make good use of the nation’s abundant mineral resources and enhance traditional industries with new high technologies (read: boost the Three Ms). Indeed, since 2000, China has put its money where its mouth is by making an over ten-fold increase in R&D expenditures. And, the results have been impressive.

This is in sharp contrast with the United States, where, for example, the entire U.S. Bureau of Mines and its important Division of Mineral Economics was abolished in 1996.

When it comes to the critical materials necessary for a green transition, China is no paper tiger. It holds all the cards.

Steve H. Hanke is a professor of applied economics at the Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore and served on President Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisers. You can follow Hanke on Twitter (@steve_hanke).

Adrien Yataco-Chatain is chief of the economic intelligence group at the Johns Hopkins Institute for Applied Economics, Global Health, and the Study of Business Enterprise.

The views and opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and do not reflect the official position of the Daily Caller News Foundation.

Content created by The Daily Caller News Foundation is available without charge to any eligible news publisher that can provide a large audience. For licensing opportunities of our original content, please contact licensing@dailycallernewsfoundation.org

Agree/Disagree with the author(s)? Let them know in the comments below and be heard by 10’s of thousands of CDN readers each day!

Support Conservative Daily News with a small donation via Paypal or credit card that will go towards supporting the news and commentary you've come to appreciate.

Related Articles

One Comment

  1. Everything the climate alarmists say is a lie and a horrible hoax. They want windmills and solar everywhere, knowing that they will be the real environmental disaster. Each wind turbine can require up to 5 acres and it takes 350 wind turbines to equal the electricity generated from one coal fired plant. So, imagine, it would take 1,750 acres of wind turbines to generate the same electricity as one traditional power plant. Offshore turbines can require up to 200 acres, and now we learn that the sonar mapping needed for offshore windmills is killing the whales like the land windmills are killing our endangered eagles. We can watch in real time Europe collapsing after decades of their “Green New Deal” policies made them totally dependent on Russian gas and oil. In some places, energy costs have increased 1000% and businesses are closing because they can’t afford their utility bills. They’re clear cutting their forests and desperately digging again for coal.

    What’s even more insane is that Biden and the Democrats last year passed their 730 billion dollar Green Energy bill, laughably called the “Inflation Reduction Act”, to institute all these proven failed policies here. It’s nothing but a Green New Deal slush fund that includes such insanity as 60 billion dollars for “environmental justice”. And then there’s the four or five states that want to ban gas powered cars by 2030. Never mind that most of the rare earth minerals for car batteries are mined in China or in Africa by child slave labor. Or that the cobalt and lithium mines are a dangerous environmental hazard. And never mind that windmills and solar only have an effective shelf life of about twenty years and there is no environmentally safe way to dispose of them when they expire (how do you dispose of tens of thousands of 351 ft. indestructible and non-degradable windmill blades). Or that almost all of our solar panels come from China. Or that China is the worst polluting country in the world and is building a new coal fired plant (1140 so far) every week and laughing at our idiocy and how we will continue to make them rich.

    Americans need to wake up before it’s too late and realize that the middle class will be bankrupted by our own government’s never ending money printing (which is the main cause of inflation) and the ever increasing taxes and higher and higher energy costs that will result from their idiotic “Green” policies and mandates.

Back to top button